The Trouble with Thomas: The Controversies of St Thomas Becket

Becket continues to be an enduring figure of controversy in the public eye. Why was he considered a saint in the first place?
In a 2006 BBC poll, St Thomas Becket (c. 1120-70) was voted one of the worst Britons of all time. While the poll was subject to its own share of controversies, the fact remains that Becket continues to be an enduring figure of controversy in the public eye. What prompted such a reaction towards Becket? Why was he considered a saint in the first place?


Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury, is probably best known in history for his infamous clashes with King Henry II of England in the 12th century. What started as a supposedly close relationship between king and clerk eventually led to a irreconcilable falling out as Church clashed with State. Their drama culminated with four knights from Henry's court who went to Christ Church in Canterbury to confront Becket. When the archbishop remained defiant, he met a grisly end, dying at the altar with the top of his skull severed. In death, however, he seemed to have the last laugh. His murder in the cathedral was seen as martyrdom, which resonated with the medieval people. An immense following built up after his death, with reports of miraculous healing occurring near his place of death, and ecclesiastical writers hastened to promote his cult with a flurry of hagiographical writings. The cult became so widespread, in fact, that it overtook St Cuthbert's cult in Durham as the most popular saint cult in England during the late Middle Ages, eventually reaching an international level of fame. The impact of Becket's cult was not limited to hagiography either. The pilgrims in Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales travel to Canterbury to pay their respects to St Thomas Becket's shrine. Clearly Becket's cult had appealed to many different members of society by the end of the fourteenth century. For a holy man lauded as the most popular saint in England during the late Middle Ages, however, the question remains: what generated such polarised controversy?

http://historytoday.com/curtis-runstedler/trouble-thomas-controversies-st-thomas-becket